WATCH: We tried the Mystery OREO!

Winneconne, WI - 20 September 2019: A package of limited edition mystery oreo cookies on an isolated background. Photo: shutterstock


OREO released a new mystery flavor for 2019. You can register to win $50,000 if you guess the flavor correctly here. According to OREO, “Mystery OREO is your chance to indulge your inner detective.”

Today, we tried the new Mystery OREOs so you don’t have too. (Unless you want too!)

Our final predictions:

Jai: Teddy Grahams

Fletch: Cinnamon Graham Cracker

Monica: Churro

Have you tried the Mystery OREO? What do you think the flavor is? Vote in our poll below:

[ss-promo op_id=”625333″ op_guid=”2c11dcaf-fc9e-463c-9905-df62d18bfec3″ routing=”hash”]

 

Recent Headlines

14 hours ago in Lifestyle, Trending

With caviar McNuggets and heart-shaped pizza, fast food chains hope to win Valentine’s diners

It's a tale as old as time, or at least as old as TikTok: chicken nuggets lovingly topped with a dab of caviar. McDonald's is embracing the trend this Valentine's Day with a limited-time McNugget Caviar kit. The free kit, which will be available on McNuggetCaviar.com on Feb. 10, pairs a one-ounce tin of Paramount's Siberian sturgeon caviar with a $25 McDonald's gift card to buy McNuggets.

22 hours ago in National, Trending

‘Today’ show host Savannah Guthrie asks for prayers to help bring her missing mom home

"Today" show host Savannah Guthrie is asking for prayers to help bring home her 84-year-old mother, whom authorities in Arizona believe was kidnapped, abducted or otherwise taken against her will.

2 days ago in Entertainment, Music, Trending

Bad Bunny wins album of the year at the 2026 Grammy Awards, a first for a Spanish-language album

Bad Bunny won album of the year at the 2026 Grammy Awards for his critically-acclaimed "Debí Tirar Más Fotos," closing out a surprising and history-making night. It is the first time a Spanish-language album has taken home the top prize.

2 days ago in Sports, Trending

Carlos Alcaraz beats Novak Djokovic to become the youngest man to complete a career Grand Slam

Carlos Alcaraz is 22, he's the youngest man ever to win all four of the major titles in tennis, and he had to achieve what no man previously has done to complete the career Grand Slam in Australia.

2 days ago in National, Trending

Punxsutawney Phil is said to have seen his shadow, forecasting 6 more weeks of wintry weather

Punxsutawney Phil predicted six more weeks of wintry weather Monday, a forecast sure to disappoint many after what's already been a long, cold season across large parts of the United States.